shape
carat
color
clarity

which diamond???

Kellyco

Rough_Rock
Premium
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
65
Hey everyone. I know I did this backwards but i purchased an upgrade diamond from Wf and I would love your opinions.
I had been talking to Liza for about a month, sent in my current diamond and had decided on this stone
https://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/princess-cut-loose-diamond-3818574.htm

I had looked here and there to see if any other diamonds popped up because I wanted to be around this size and there isn't much. Well yesterday was the day, I did the wire transfer but just before that found this diamond just added - I talked to Liza and i decided to switch And buy this one.
https://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/princess-cut-loose-diamond-3935431.htm

It seemed to me she thought the first one was a great choice but She asked me if I was concerned at all about the color and clarity and I am.. so that's why we went with the second one.
I paid about $650 more and feel like I got a deal! But am I missing something? Is there light leakage? I really have tried to understand the images and I did my best. SO I bought this one. they are holding it because they're going to set it for me. So if i made a bad choice I'm sure I could switch back to the other- 1.283. To be honest the I color and Si1 was making me nervous. But I keep thinking. Was the other better performance wise?.. what do you think? I'm not worried about the $$ as much as did I choose the better diamond? The I si1 is a tad larger as well but not much.

I appreciate your expertise so much! I love the honesty and helpfulness here. I read all the time. thank you!!

I should add WF has been wonderful, patient, not pushy so helpful and honest. It's a relief to be in good hands with such a purchase.
 
Either one will be spectacular. I prefer the higher color and clarity.
 
Either one will be spectacular. I prefer the higher color and clarity.

Thank you! That's what I figured but the close pics throw me off for some reason. I'm probably being silly worrying about it. I appreciate your reassurance!
 
They are both AGS000 graded stones with ideal light return so any leakage would have to be minimal. They both look like beautiful stones but
I like the higher color H...I think a small trade off in size vs color is worth it.

Post pictures when you get it!
 
Thank you! I will post pics! It’s going to be about 4 weeks If not more because I want a vatche setting. Ahhhh I’m practicing patience.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top