by kingfish » Oct 28, 2008 I'm about to buy an e-ring and these are the two stones I have on hold and I'm looking at. I'd appreciate your advice. Both seem to be pretty good stones from what I can tell. The second is a bit less expensive. Which would you guys recommend? Diamond 1 Proportions: Depth: 60.3 % Table: 58 % Crown Angle: 35° Pavilion Angle: 40.6° Star length: 50 % Lower Half: 80 % Girdle: Thin to Medium, Faceted Culet: None Diamond 2 Proportions: Depth: 62.4 % Table: 54.9 % Crown Angle: 35.5° Pavilion Angle: 40.5° Star length: 50 % Lower Half: 80 % Girdle: 1.9%-4.3% Culet: None Both do pretty well on the HCA, with the second having a slightly smaller spread. I'd appreciate all your thoughts, thanks in advance!