What to do with a spare engagement ring?

[pinkprashu]

So I recently upgraded my ER and now have 2 ER's and I have decided not to sel my original ER. I am attaching the pictures of my original ER. Would you wear that as a right hand ring? I tried that one day and liked it. My right and left hands ring fingers are the same size. If I decided to wear it that way, do you think it is too much???

 

[SB621]

I"m not a fan my RHR looking like an ering. I would either pop out the diamond and add a colored stone. Or recycle the ring into something else.

 

[nala]

I find it hard to wear a solitaire on my right hand. I reserve that hand for bands, cocktail rings, etc. bc it just feels uncomfortable and doesn't look good,in my opinion. I have an old mine cut solitaire that I love and I reserve it for my traveling ring instead of wearing it as a rhr.

 

[Rena7]

If you like the look than wear it. It is a beautiful ring.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I'd buy two side stones and have it made into a 3 stone ring. I really don't like a solitaire diamond on the right hand especially if one is being worn on the other hand.

 

[two_little_birds]

I had my original ER reset and now wear it on my RH. I love it!

I say go for whatever makes you comfortable. Personally I wanted to keep my diamond in a ring (instead of a pedant, or pairing it up for studs, etc.)

 

[pinkprashu]

I am on ban island right now so I cannot spend any more money the rest of the year but I like the idea of making it a 3 stone. I don't know if I can convert my existing setting into a 3/4 eternity band instead of selling it. What do you think?

 

[CharmyPoo]

Rotate once in a while.

 

[m-2-b]

A pendant or 3 stone (Trois brilliant) would be great alternatives!

 

[marcy]

The ring is very pretty. If you like it as a RHR then you should wear it and enjoy it.

 

[babs23r]

I would make it into a pendant. You could bezel the center stone and pave the remaining diamonds around it, or put a halo setting around the stone.

 

[TracyBear]

I am on ban island right now so I cannot spend any more money the rest of the year but I like the idea of making it a 3 stone. I don't know if I can convert my existing setting into a 3/4 eternity band instead of selling it. What do you think?

For now, since you can't spend any money, just wear it as it is. My mom has two E-rings that she alternates accordingly to her outfits and the occasion that she's attending. She wears the smaller diamond if she's going to a shady or a conservative religious area. The larger stone is for weddings and personal get togethers. Answer to your original question: yes, I do think wearing two similar diamond rings on both ring fingers simultaneously is a bit awkward. I wouldn't wear them together, but I'm not you. Do what brings you joy!

Later when you have the cash, you can do whatever your heart desires. Both the 3 stone ring and 3/4 eternity band sounds like a miraculous idea!