shape
carat
color
clarity

What’s the difference between 2.5 carats and 1.8 degrees in a round?

0-0-0

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Jul 30, 2010
Messages
1,308
Big size difference. Nuanced cut differences. Both HPHT grown with blue nuance.
Carat4.126.62
ColorFfaint blue G
ClarityVS1VS1
Measurements10.37 - 10.42 x 6.26 mm11.95 - 12.01 x 7.45 mm
Depth60.3%62.2%
Table58%57%
Crown Angle3435.8
Crown Height14.5%15.5%
Pavilion Angle40.740.7
Pavilion Depth43%43%
4.12
IMG_2265.jpeg
IMG_2269.jpeg

6.62
IMG_2264.jpeg
IMG_2268.jpeg

Rounds this big sit high on my holding tray, so the amount of blue obstruction is exaggerated. The 6.62 is right on the edge of showing leakage under the table. It shows leakage under the table with the slightest tilt, similar to 34.5/41 in Cutwise’s Pa variation for Ca34.5, the 4.12 looks similar to 34.5/40.6. https://cutwise.com/~-bOV

Pardon the lint in my videos

The 4.12 F has white phosphorescence that fades to light yellow and the 6.62 G has light yellow phosphorescence that fades to white. Other than this interesting oddity the color is comparable. In person, the slight increase in crown height is more noticeable than the difference in color.
IMG_2262.jpeg

2.57 E vs 4.12 F vs 2.62 faint blue G for reference

Other than size, the biggest difference to me between them is in the way they handle light. The 6.62 arrows stay more silvery whereas the 4.12 arrows go dark at closer than half arm’s length. With the 6.62, the leakage areas that show up under the table on tilt move as the stone moves, giving the illusion of more contrast and a more lively center. As such, when the arrows are all silvery at full arm’s length, the 6.62 has a slightly more interesting contrast pattern.

Both are attractive rounds with different personalities. Both are capable of generating fire strong enough to necessitate averting my eyes. Setting choice is likely to have a bigger impact on the 6.62 given the leakage areas on tilt.
 

Kim N

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Oct 6, 2005
Messages
6,463
Your comparisons are always so informative and interesting. Please continue to share them!
 

0-0-0

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Jul 30, 2010
Messages
1,308
I’ll keep at it as long as my budget allows! :lol: Pricescope has been very helpful in my searches over the years and this is my way of giving back. =)2
 

0515vision

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Jan 16, 2023
Messages
849
@0-0-0, just love these posts!
Such a great example of how jewelers’ spotlights can flood stones and obscure nuanced areas of leakage/obstruction, etc.
 
Be a part of the community Get 3 HCA Results
Top