WF A cut above how do I choose

[cherij0411]

Hi

I know this is a top cut, my question is If I am looking at 4 choices all ideal cut, a cut above how do I choose which one is better (if same color and clarity)? Thanks

 

[foxinsox]

You go with which one meets your colour/clarity/size requirements best.. or whichever one your eyes like the most since they do all look different with thinner or fatter arrows and the like..

 

[cherij0411]

You go with which one meets your colour/clarity/size requirements best.. or whichever one your eyes like the most since they do all look different with thinner or fatter arrows and the like..

Thank you I love your dogs!

 

[rockysalamander]

My criteria would favor fat arrows and smaller table.Like @foxinsox said, it comes down to visual preference. But, I'd also consult with the WF gemologist to get their thoughts.

 

[foxinsox]

Thank you I love your dogs!

Thanks - they’re cute little nuggets and a lot of fun! Please come back and show us handshots of which diamond you choose - we love to see diamonds!

 

[valeria101]

.

It is rather nice to choose without worying about 'why' ...

I tend to the same slightly broader facets as @rockysalamande - in theory. Would not be too surprised if a long lgf-ed RBC becconed one day, since this detail seems to work with some proportions better, etc. & I am not quite sure what the rules are.

 

[marcy]

I told the kind lady I was working with at WF what was most important to me and bought my ACA based on her suggestion. I totally trusted her judgement and I certainly wasn't disappointed. With ACA's you know they are going to be beautiful. They may be able to make you a video of the diamonds side by side if you want to pick them yourself.

 

[ringo865]

Or (after you put them on hold) post them here for experienced PSers analysis of each.