URGENT!!! E 1.09 VS1 and E 1.01 VS2 - which is better

[newbuyer]

All comments welcome pls - am thinking of buying this weekend!E VS1 1.09
HRD
Brilliant
No Flouresence
6.64 x 6.70 x 4.11
very good
very good
girdle - thin 2%
culet - 0.4% polished
table - 59%
crown height - 15%
pavillion depth - 44.5%
E VS2 1.01
GIA
Brilliant
No Flouresence
6.32 x 6.43 x 3.97
very good
very good
girdle - slightly thick to thick
culet - small
table - 60%
depth - 62.3%Is it ok to set the two stones in a 6 claw platinum setting?Many thanks!!

 

[pricescope]

Hi Newbuyer,I plugged data for the first diamond into the Cut Adviser - only 6.2 (Fair) result. Pavilion is too deep.It is difficult to evaluate the second one since GIA doesn't provide info on crown and pavilion. However, with 60% table and 62.3% depth there is a good chance that it is a deep cut too.I wouldn't risk to recommend neither one of them unless you have seen many other diamonds (including ideal cuts) and happy with their look and price.

 

[diamondmanbob]

Hi,
We don't know how much those two diamonds are but if you would go back to the home page here on Pricescope and click on "search by visual performance", I think you would find several diamonds within your requirements and price range that would out perform the two diamonds above.
Also, don't get in a big hurry to pick out this most important and long lasting diamond.
dimondbob