Torn between TWO. Please help me choose!

[CSammy]

So I have been searching for the perfect diamond for months now. I'be finally narrowed down to two but I need help to decide which one to pick! I'm asking for diamond experts to help me decide please. I have seen one of the diamonds in person and I guess I liked it, but I didn't get to compare with others side by side since it was at a wholesale office. They're both round brilliant. The specs for each diamond is as follow:

Diamond #1 (the one that I've seen)

- hearts and arrow: No
- measurements: 8.40 - 8.43 x 5.22 mm
- carat weight: 2.28
- color grade: G
- clarity grade: SI1
- cut grade: Excellent
- polish: Excellent
- symmetry: Excellent
- fluourencence: Strong Blue
- depth: 62%
- table: 56%
- crown: 35.0
- pavilion: 40.6
- girdle: Slightly Thick
- faceted: 4.0%
- cutlet: none

Diamond #2 (only pictures)

- hearts and arrow: Yes
- measurements: 8.37 - 8.39 x 5.24 mm
- carat weight: 2.27
- color grade: G
- clarity grade: SI1
- cut grade: Excellent
- polish: Excellent
- symmetry: Excellent
- fluourencence: Medium Blue
- depth: 62.5%
- table: 57%
- crown: 35.0
- pavilion: 41.0
- girdle: Medium to Slightly Thick
- faceted: 4.0%
- cutlet: none

Any suggestions are appreciated! FYI, the second diamond is about $1,000 cheaper.