Thoughts on this stone?

[jsmp1225]

1.15 G SI1 74% 73% GIA tnsk no vg vg no 5.68*5.62*4.16 4038*‡


It''s from Whiteflash and seems like a pretty good deal. Will be set in either yellow gold or platinum solitaire.

 

[jsmp1225]

Or this one:

1.21 G SI1 72.9% 75% GIA gd vg no 5.74x5.72x4.17 $4504*?

Substantial difference for an extra $500?

 

[aljdewey]

These are princess stones, I presume?




(They definitely aren't rounds!)

 

[jsmp1225]

Yes, they are princess stones. Sorry for not specifying in my original posts.