Super ideal cut proportion? Pls help to pick one..(Ideal, ASET H&A pics provided)

[Rance]

Hey guys which one would you pick up?
1.02CT E/VS1 $8863USD







1.08CT D/VS2 $9558USD




Hey guys which one would you pick up?

 

[lovedogs]

A few questions: Does your GF specifically want a D/E stone? You could get something larger that is G/VS2 and looks very white and is 100% eye clean.

With your budget you could afford a super ideal stone from a vendor with a $1 upgrade policy, which is a really nice feature to have.

Did you run those stones through the HCA to make sure they score under 2?

 

[whitewave]

Right, D and E (while blindingly lucious and delicious ) are somewhat of maybe paying for things you can’t see. F is basically just as good— but I admit I love a D color.

Of those two (hard choice), I’d choose one because I prefer fatter arrows with the 75% LGF. 80% is not a deal breaker, but I personally choose 75 over 80.

 

[Slickk]

Of those two (hard choice), I’d choose one because I prefer fatter arrows with the 75% LGF. 80% is not a deal breaker, but I personally choose 75 over 80.[/QUOTE]

This! I like fatter arrows as well and I would not need a D personally. An E would be white enough for me.