Find your diamond
Find your jewelry
shape
carat
color
clarity

stone options for sugarloaf ring?

MMtwo

MMtwo

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Sep 20, 2009
Messages
5,141
Hi CS folks. I have always wanted a sugarloaf ring (bullet-shaped cabochon). With it's smooth finish, I am wondering if a sapphire would scuff over time? Are there any other well-wearing stone contenders you might suggest?

Thanks in advance!
 
With it having a smooth surface (no facets at the crown), it is less likely to be scuffed or chip, unlike a faceted stone. The only concern is the very top, but even then, it's pretty safe if worn with care.
 
I think any cabochon can scuff up. It depends how hard you are on your jewelry. However, sapphire being extremely hard, it’s less likely to scuff up then an opal or a moonstone, which can lose their polish over time.
 
Thank you @chrono and @TL
I gather sapphire would probably be at the top of the list for cab choices. Thank you for your input.
Generally, I am pretty easy on jewelry, being a lady of a certain (ahem) age, I am not doing much more than deskwork and dishes.
 
JPie said:
I have this untreated ruby sugarloaf, and I managed to scratch the ruby right away. :cry2:

1572029216408.png
Click to expand...

Jpie no - that must have been heart breaking. That ring is everything perfect about a sugarloaf. A wet looking colorful gumdrop of jewel goodness. I wonder if someone could buff it out without too much trouble. It's a beautiful design.





PreRaphaelite said:
I can’t help at all but wanted to share this onyx sugarloaf ring:

1572029378331.jpeg
Click to expand...

Oh that is FABULOUS!. It definitely helped. I love designs that have that deco design look. Yummy!
 
Anyone and everyone PLEASE post your delicious sugarloaf rings here!
 
@moneymeister I was upset at the time and thought about getting it polished, but I decided that since I have no intention of selling it & abrasion happens, I may as well think of it like wrinkles increasing with age.
 
JPie said:
@moneymeister I was upset at the time and thought about getting it polished, but I decided that since I have no intention of selling it & abrasion happens, I may as well think of it like wrinkles increasing with age.
Click to expand...
It’s so beautiful. Is it Kataoka?
 
Sapphire. Lots more emeralds but I think that's too fragile for such an exposed setting. If you go emerald, I would absolutely insure it and wear it sparingly.

Jade is "softer" but incredibly tough for a cab -- but a nice color, nice translucency piece would be five figures and not your "sugarloaf" shape.

I agree it's a great look. Spouse has a very purple star sapphire that is like a jellybean. I like a transparent sugarloaf better but not really compatible with an asterism.
 
LilAlex said:
Sapphire. Lots more emeralds but I think that's too fragile for such an exposed setting. If you go emerald, I would absolutely insure it and wear it sparingly.

Jade is "softer" but incredibly tough for a cab -- but a nice color, nice translucency piece would be five figures and not your "sugarloaf" shape.

I agree it's a great look. Spouse has a very purple star sapphire that is like a jellybean. I like a transparent sugarloaf better but not really compatible with an asterism.
Click to expand...

LilAlex, I agree that emerald is a little too fragile for a daily wear ring. I do love the look though. The jade idea is a great one and I had not thought of that. While the shape is not the coveted gumdrop, a beautiful antique jade cab is a great idea for a daily wear ring. I have recently become interested in jade, so that would be a nice choice. Although, my budget does not go into the imperial range, I might find a bit of translucent apple jade that would fit the bill.

I have also considered a star sapphire. I bet the spouses' ring is lovely. It's on the short list of interesting items to be sure. Also a ruby star would be nice.

There is no shortage of options, is there?

Heh, I am off to Ruby Lane to explore jade cab rings :)
 
@moneymeister I stumbled upon this sapphire sugarloaf and thought of you. The price is crazy but I figured the design is still good inspiration.

foxandbond.com

Edwardian Natural Sugarloaf Sapphire and Diamond Platinum Engagement Ring

The Story A sapphire and diamond ring set in platinum from the late Edwardian era. Sitting at the center is a striking sugarloaf cabochon sapphire, natural and unheated, with a unique four-point shape. Bezel set and made by hand to fit the stone, it's surrounded by a geometric floral design...
foxandbond.com foxandbond.com

2482590E-5CC6-4552-9A01-D5DA6DEDA01B.pngD10A4171-4BFA-4A3C-9F82-A8E146CFC66F.pngC013D677-05FC-4CD9-97A0-3B402F399A37.png
 
JPie said:
@moneymeister I stumbled upon this sapphire sugarloaf and thought of you. The price is crazy but I figured the design is still good inspiration.

foxandbond.com

Edwardian Natural Sugarloaf Sapphire and Diamond Platinum Engagement Ring

The Story A sapphire and diamond ring set in platinum from the late Edwardian era. Sitting at the center is a striking sugarloaf cabochon sapphire, natural and unheated, with a unique four-point shape. Bezel set and made by hand to fit the stone, it's surrounded by a geometric floral design...
foxandbond.com foxandbond.com

2482590E-5CC6-4552-9A01-D5DA6DEDA01B.pngD10A4171-4BFA-4A3C-9F82-A8E146CFC66F.pngC013D677-05FC-4CD9-97A0-3B402F399A37.png
Click to expand...

What beauty and unusual. Completely out of my wheelhouse, financially (honey would shoot me), but a great example of an inspiration ring. I love the fine level of craftsmanship in just about everything made long ago.
 
Not a sugarloaf but I've banged my Jade cab a few times and it's been fine. Not a scratch.

I've also banged the more delicate Jade flower carved rings and they've all been fine. The moh score is low but it seems really tough to me.
 
PreRaphaelite said:
Just another option, this one in 18k white gold and a live auction ending tomorrow. Just sharing, in case anyone likes it. I think the setting is gorgeous!

3D2324E6-A936-42F1-94A8-48722DE9B1FB.jpeg

www.shopgoodwill.com

Used Vintage 14K Gold Etched Onyx Size 6 Ring HS336

www.shopgoodwill.com www.shopgoodwill.com
Click to expand...

Absolutely beautiful and very unique. I love the carving on the stone.
I'm having a 16 x 12 rounded top-grade polar jade cabochon cut for a ring. Not a true sugarloaf, but will be a happy daily wear ring. I am on a jade binge right now. Etsy shop JadeCarvingCanada. I also picked up a blue Guatemalan bead and a leaf pendant from the same vendor (vendor's photos).

il_794xN.1866190852_5vly.jpgil_794xN.2122322201_gbcd.jpg
 
Edit...that blue bead is a natural blue jade colors.
 
I guess my Ruby counts as a sugar loaf.

590465

DK :))
 
dk168 said:
I guess my Ruby counts as a sugar loaf.

rubycluster_02.jpg

DK :))
Click to expand...

It’s wonderful, domed goodness is welcome to the party. I would love a ruby ring like that one.
 
dk168 said:
I guess my Ruby counts as a sugar loaf.

rubycluster_02.jpg

DK :))
Click to expand...

Actually DK, a good ruby is on my bucket list. I am very leery of anything I can afford :) Synthetics are great but not mind clean.
 
I have 2 rings, a jade and a pink tourmaline. They both are pre loved and there is not a scratch on them.
 

Attachments

  • 20191111_080709.jpg
    20191111_080709.jpg
    117.4 KB · Views: 123
  • 20191111_080648.jpg
    20191111_080648.jpg
    136.8 KB · Views: 129
  • 20191111_080622.jpg
    20191111_080622.jpg
    133.7 KB · Views: 91
You must log in or register to reply here.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP

Featured Topics

Jewelry Blog
PriceScope-Concierge-Ad
Find prime cuts.
Top