Stats for these stones?

[DiamondsNPearls]

One is a cushion from JA, the other an emerald cut (good cut)





Here are the stats on the emerald, I hope image is not too big.

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

stats are useless for fancy shapes. 10,000 more variables than for a round diamond

 

[tyty333]

We really need to see a video of the two stones. Asets images by any change? Post um if you got um!

 

[Matthews1127]

Not sure what this post is asking...?
Cushions & EC’s are fancy cut diamonds, and cannot be evaluated on certs/stats, alone.
Even static photos aren’t enough to evaluate a fancy cut diamond.
Cushions and EC’s have nothing in common; you’re comparing apples to bananas.
Which cut do you prefer over the other? Is this stone for you, or are you searching for someone else? If someone else, which is their preference?
These stones will perform very differently, so narrowing down preference will be helpful to begin evaluation...even comparison to others within those criteria, and budget.
Please request ASET images, and post videos of each/any stones you are considering for evaluation.