shape
carat
color
clarity

Somebody reassure me...ASET / IS images

ryan23

Rough_Rock
Joined
Jul 16, 2017
Messages
50
So I'm driving myself nuts here, probably without good reason. I went back and forth on even posting this, but I wanted some peace of mind.

I recently bought a ring from IDJ and only afterwards did I remember to request the ASET/IS images. While I fully trust IDJ, and Yekutial reassured me the stone is fine, AND I have seen it in person 3x, the images were a bit odd to me. Having this (hopefully) be a one time purchase, and spending quite a bit of money on it, I just want to make sure I'm not buying a bad diamond.

Stone's #'s are: 1.72, J, SI1, Medium Blue Fluorescence, Depth 61.2, Table 57, Crown 34, Pavilion 40.6, HCA 0.7.
Images attached. The green blob at the 7 o'clock and the broken arrow at the 1 o'clock freaked me out. I now understand after reading through about 30 threads here that the green blob is fine. So should I worry about that broken arrow?

I will say this:

- I fully understand I'm not paying for a hearts and arrows stone. In fact, this same stone at Whiteflash would probably be 2x the amount honestly. But I'm fine without a H&A designation as long as it doesn't impact fire/brilliance.
- I've seen the stone in person 3x. It looked good to me. By itself it is quite fiery.
- I did compare it to a JA True Hearts stone (1.51, J, VS1, Strong Blue Fluorescence, Depth 61.2, Table 55, Crown 34, Pavilion 40.8, HCA 1.0.) While I did notice the JA stone was slightly more fiery, it was not significant. But I did notice it. Still, this is 1.72 vs. 1.51 and both I and Yekutial thought the size was a better choice.
- Here is a gif of the two stones side by side: https://giphy.com/gifs/NSsLy90iLYXw4/html5

With all that said, I'm a novice to all this and I can't read these images that well despite trying. Is there anything in these images that would be a basis to disqualify this stone?

GIA 6255764909-ASET  black (Fancy)-01.jpg GIA 6255764909-ASET  white-01.jpg GIA  6255764909-Officelight black-01.jpg GIA  6255764909-IdealScope-01.jpg
 
The diamond is badly tilted in these photos. The length and size of the arrows are all different.
But if it bothers you, ask IDJ to retake the ASET with white ground.

I fully understand I'm not paying for a hearts and arrows stone. In fact, this same stone at Whiteflash would probably be 2x the amount honestly. But I'm fine without a H&A designation as long as it doesn't impact fire/brilliance.
And I think that's exactly what you got. Great job
 
I think you've traded off all the variables nicely and have ended up with a great-looking, not-small stone :)
 
Agree with above posters...it's a beautiful non-super ideal stone!
 
If yekutiel recommends it over the other, I'd go for it. The image looks like it will perform well, and who doesn't want a bigger stone. ? :)
 
It passes both ASET and IS tests.
Its not as close to perfect as some but it is a solid pass.
 
Thanks everyone. I don't really need new pictures, was just making sure I wasn't missing anything. I fully trust Yekutial but just needed some PS reassurance as well :D
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top