Round brilliant diamond. Is this too much?

[RonTheConfused]

Hi,

AGS Grading Report:

Price: $3,874
Carat: 0.736
Cut: AGS Ideal 0
=> polish ideal
=> symmetry ideal
=> proportions ideal
Color: F
Clarity: VS2
Depth %: 61.0
Table %: 57.0
Girdle %: 1.2 to 1.7 (faceted)
Crown Angle: 35.0 deg
Pavillion Angle: 40.6 deg

It''s sold as a "special" ideal and comes with two reports. Halloway Cut Advisor rates is as a 0.7 or 0.9.

According to pricescope is should only sell at $2890?? But I have a hard time finding any diamonds with a better HCA score and AGS Ideal without a very thin girdle. I''m buying it for an engagement ring.

I appreciate your help!

-- Ron

 

[niceice]

What is "special" about it? Looks like a pretty normal ideal cut diamond to us... What two reports accompany the diamond?

 

[RonTheConfused]

Thanks for replying, niceice!

It has AGSL and GCAT reports. AGSL is industry-standard. GCAT is Blue Nile's "double-check".

They marked it as signature ideal, because according to their own measuremnts it's slightly better:
=> Table: 57.7%
=> Depth: 60.9%
=> Crown: 34.9 degress
=> Pavil: 40.4 degrees

I give the AGSL more weight. Is this a fair asking price.. is it far off?

-- Ron

 

[Giangi]

From the data you've provided in the last post, the stone is AGS 1!!!!!!!