rookie needs help comparing

[darkwing_1978]

I'm hoping that someone will be able to help me compare these three round diamonds.

I used the cut adviser and they all came up pretty much the same 1 or 1.1

From what I can tell (which is a very rookie opinion based on the few things that I've been able to pick up from this forum they're pretty much the same.

Can you guys let me know if you see any glaring differences or problems with any of the three? What I'm wondering about is the difference in Girdle, and how much of a difference there is between F & G colour

thanks in advance!!!!!

Chris

Stone 1

.434
G
VS2
depth 61.5
Table 57
Crown angle 33.9
Pavilion Angle 41
Culet - Pointed
Girdle - 1.2%-1.9%
price - $1085

Stone 2

.436
VS2
F
depth 60.4
Table 57
Crown Angle - 33.9
Pavilion angle - 41
Culet - Pointed
Girdle - 1.0% - 1.6%
Price $1175

Stone 3

.456
VS2
F
Depth 61.5
Table 56
Crown 34.2
Pavilion 40.9
Girdle 1%-1.6%
price $1229

 

[pricescope]

Hi Chris,

Looks like you've selected very pretty H&A stones! I don’t see a problem with any of them.

If I’m not mistaken, you could get the first two a bit cheaper if would mention Pricescope name:

0.434 G VS2 61.5% 57% AGS 1.2-1.9 pt id id no 4.84-4.87x2.99 $1031*
0.436 F VS2 60.4% 57% AGS 1.0-1.6 pt id id no 4.91-4.94x2.98 $1116*

F vs G is a matter of personal preferences. You probably won't see a difference in everyday life.

Good luck

 

[fire&ice]

----------------
On 10/4/2002 10:51:22 PM

Hi Chris,

Looks like you've selected very pretty H&A stones! I don’t see a problem with any of them.

If I’m not mistaken, you could get the first two a bit cheaper if would mention Pricescope name:

0.434 G VS2 61.5% 57% AGS 1.2-1.9 pt id id no 4.84-4.87x2.99 $1031*
0.436 F VS2 60.4% 57% AGS 1.0-1.6 pt id id no 4.91-4.94x2.98 $1116*

F vs G is a matter of personal preferences. You probably won't see a difference in everyday life.

Good luck


----------------

Nice picks. ..and certainly worth mentioning pricescope for a price break!

I think I would go w/ the F b/c it's a little larger.

But, I wonder if one would perceive such? Leonid?

 

[pricescope]

----------------
I think I would go w/ the F b/c it's a little larger.

But, I wonder if one would perceive such? Leonid?
----------------


0.05 mm or 1% difference in diameter... I think the difference is rather small although it might be nice to know.