Thanks everyone for your replies. I hope every decision won't be this difficult, but I have a feeling this is the easy one!
MustangGal - I have a hunch, based on your comment and other comments I've read on-line that I would not like glider (though I would like the fact that it does not move off the floor.) I really should just go try them in the store, and probably will one day, but I think I'm going to get this rocker. It's a pity you didn't use your rocker/recliner! You should sell it on Craigslist!
Hudson - Oh, thank you for helping me feel less crazy! I didn't realize that you were only 6 weeks when you got your stroller, but I remember when you posted about it. I want to visit that outlet! That's my same thought - to spread the expenditures out over a period of time. I don't know how I will ever decide on a stroller. I think I might have to get a therapist to get me through it. Haha!! Anyway, yes, the PB rocker does have a removable slip cover, and it looks to be in good condition. I think they sell slipcovers that will fit PB furniture on eBay too. I love PB, but I am more of CL PB kind of girl! Not willing to spend the big bucks!
Packrat - Thank you for your input! My only regret about this rocker is that it does not recline. Grrrr, but it is too cute and a great price, so I'm just going to get it.
so cal girl - Wow, you got my favorite kind of deal - Free! You are right, I can always sell it if it doesn't work out, or even use it in another bedroom!
ChinaCat - There are cats and dogs all over my house at this point, haha (ok, only 7) but we will be down to our standard three cats and two dogs again soon. I think we plan to keep them more or less out of the nursery, but I do see the concern re: dogs, cats and little hands getting caught. I do wish it reclined. No ottoman either. The seller suggested this
nursing stool, but I just don't see how that would be comfortable, so maybe I will find a cute little coordinating ottoman somewhere along the way.