rock size

[bobby]

Which one would you choose?

1. G, 1.06 carats, SI1, Good Cut(Gem Scan) OR
2. G, 1.0 carats, SI1, Ideal Cut(Gem Scan)


I'm noticing both are demanding same price.

PS. Gem scan uses Ideal, Very Good, Good, Medium, & Fair.

 

[student]

I don't know what Gem scan is or what its standards are, but with such a small difference in size if the difference in cut is significant it could make much more of a difference.

 

[jetcaptain]

Of these two, I would buy the ideal cut diamond. It almost certainly will look better, and may even look bigger, especially if the good cut diamond's tiny bit of extra weight is wasted by being cut too deep.

 

[fire&ice]

Not enough information to compute. What is the measurements of the stones? What are the table & Depth %'s? Which one visually looks better?