I am making my decision either today or Monday and I am looking for some reassurance. A friend of a friend is local and has a 1.12 Marquis D VS1 62.3% depth and 54% Table. This cut appears to be very good to me, and the price of 6,350 seems great. I know it's not the optimum table size, but as far as brilliance, would I and/or my hopefully future fiance notice a difference if the table was more like 58%. The lighting in the jewelers studio is terrible, she doesn't normally show there, so I couldn't tell. Most people are telling me I am being picky and getting crazy, but I just want to get my money's worth. It is a little bit smaller than I really wanted, so I don't want to sacrifice noticeable brilliance as well.