QUICK OPINION

[AMF515]

need some quick opinions on the following w/ limited info at this time. Hope it's enough to get me started.

Both Emerald cut GIA's

#1.


Shape EMERALD
Weight 1.19
Color G
Clarity VS1
Depth 68.5
Table 68
Measurement 7.24*5.24*3.59MM


#2.

Shape EMERALD
Weight 1.23
Color H
Clarity VS1
Depth 75.6
Table 63
Measurement 6.97*4.99*3.77MM

 

[Richard Sherwood]

Number 1 gets my attention. Notice that even though it's a smaller carat weight, it has a larger surface area. The depth and table size are close, and in a good percentage range, which is usually a good thing in terms of performance.

How are the prices?

 

[canadiangrrl]

#1 would be my pick, on paper, from those two stones - for the reasons Rich listed, and also because I would much rather have a G than an H in a fancy (especially a step cut.)