Princess specs...are they good?

[jetmal]

hi,

ok, here are 2 of my finds. I would appreciate if you guys could comment on them.
I have seen them in person....I like them all, but of course I like the biggest one the best.
no IS or Sarins though....
thank you very much

1.52 Princess cut - this one is being sent to GIA
E/F color SI2
5.9 x 6.0
no other info as of yet
$9300


1.51 "" this one is EGL cert
I color SI1
6.34-6.10x4.32
$9600

1.71 "" interested in this one the most this one is EGL
G color - SI1
7.29 x 6.61
depth 67.(%
table 78%
$14,xxx

 

[Rod]

People here, particularly those who really know princess cuts will help, but you haven''t posted enough information to tell anything about them. Who are you buying these from? A local jeweler? on-line? Have you seen them in person? Are they graded by GIA or AGS? Do you have sarins? Were any scope images provided?

You''re missing many key measurements.

 

[jetmal]

I edited the first post

 

[jetmal]

can anyone comment on the last stone for me???
it seems to have a large table....is that ok?????

 

[Rod]

Hi and welcome to PS, but you''re still not providing enough information. One thing I can say is many of us prefer GIA or AGS graded stones to EGL. EGL often is soft in their grading reports. Is it EGL USA? Israel? Europe?

 

[belle]

very large table and shallow depth. this is a mediocre cut at best.

 

[Garysax]

Date: 2/25/2006 12:40:56 PM
Author: belle
very large table and shallow depth. this is a mediocre cut at best.

Just based on those numbers it doesn''t look like a good cut at all--you''d rather have the 78 depth and 67 table. But again, it''s possible if you''ve seen it in person and it''s great that it''s a great diamond, but I rules of thumb around here say no.