Princess Help

[rauln]

I need advice between 2 Princess cut diamonds: Need to know ASAP

1)1.51 carat F VS 1
GIA CERT
Depth/Table 72/75
Dimension 6.39 x 6.06 x 4.40 : Square modified brilliant
Good Polish / Good Symmetry
Girdle: forget
Inclusions: natural indent, feather, pinpoints mainly on pavillion; none on table
Has one extra facet
Culet and Flourescence: none
Price: $9800 at local jeweler

2) 1.35 F; IF
GIA CERT
Depth Percentage > 73.50 %
Table Percentage > 75 %
Measurements: 6.18 X 6.14 X 4.51 mm : Square modified
Price: $9718 online
Girdle > M-STK
Culet > N
Polish > Very Good
Symmetry > Very Good
Fluorescence > None

Crown height unknown

Thanks

 

[YoungPapa]

$9800 is a smokin price, especially from a local jeweler. Jewelers keep selling at those prices and I''m out of a job.

1.51 is my vote.

 

[rauln]

Thanks - I actually put a deposit on the 1.51 and want to make sure I''m getting a good diamond.

Actually the 1.35 I''ve seen on pricescope is offered anywhere from 9100-9400 depending on the vendor. I was just concerned with all the inclusions and extra facet on the 1.51 and it''s L/W ratio of 1.054 although it''s still square. It looks good though.