Possible Diamond Upgrade - Which would you pick

[ChedWick]

I'll try and keep this brief since I tend to drag things out and go into far greater detail then necessary.

I just received my custom ring from WF but I've sent it back for some minor fine-tuning. I've also been browsing their inventory and a few from the ACA selection caught my eye and I'm considering taking advantage of their upgrade policy while they still have my ring in their possession.

So if you had the option to either keep option one, or swap it out for either of the other options would you and why?


Mine:Option1

Carat- .608 Color- E Clarity- SI1

Option2

Carat- .707 Color- E Clarity- SI1

Option3

Carat- .68 Color- F Clarity-VS1

 

[Niel]

I like the 3rd one.

 

[GoSounders]

How much do options 2 and 3 cost to replace option 1?

I don't see anything wrong with your stone. Is it just the size that you'd like to change?

 

[ChedWick]

The cost increase would be roughly 600-800 dollars. Not much of a difference to me same with the size increase. I probably wont notice .1 carat. I'm more looking for how well the diamond performs/looks. If I'm not going to see a difference between my stone and either of those two I won't worry about it.

I guess I'm just second guessing myself. It seems like there may be a little more sparkle in the other two near the center due to contrast. Idk though.

 

[ChedWick]

I love would any other feedback. I believe since the size difference is only up to .2mm either stone could get set in my custom setting. I'm just not sure if I would see any real visual difference between the 3. Mine appeared very bright especially in the middle but may not have scintillated much. This could have been a product of lighting and my own mind tricks though.

 

[JulieN]

Get the biggest one if the money is inconsequential.
They look all about the same except for size.

 

[AprilBaby]

#3