PLEASE VOTE ! ...similiar settings...but Radiant or Emerald?

[ooohdiamonds]

which ring do you prefer? i need help in deciding!

they're essentially the same in many ways... except one ring contains step cut diamonds




RING 1 (EMERALD):

http://www.ringenvy.com/rings/My_Engagement_Ring!&img=


RING 2 (RADIANT):

http://www.ringenvy.com/rings/4.72_carat_Radiant_Cut_%28New_camera_phone_/_4_new_pics%21%29&img=1

 

[Mrs Mitchell]

I voted for emerald cut because I''m not a huge fan of white radiants, but also because I like step cut centre stones with step cut sides.

Have you tried on or looked at EC v radiants in person? They do have very different looks and this is really a personal preference.

Jen