Please help with upgrade

[Steffiem]

Hi again, after a year of finding a lovely diamond I am back on the hunt for something bigger

I would really value some opinions on the following three (all AGS certified) :

1) Round, 1.503, I color, VS1, Ideal.
Depth % - 62,7
Table % - 56,4
Crown Angle - 35,7
Star - 53,0
Pavilion Angle - 40,7
Crown % - 15,7
Lower Girdle % - 77,0
Culet- Pointed
Fluorescence - Negligible
Girdle - Thin to slightly thick faceted
Light Performance - Ideal
Polish - Ideal
Symmetry - Ideal

2) Round, 1.315, I color, SI1, Ideal.
Depth % - 61,0
Table % - 58,1
Crown Angle - 34,8
Star - 52,0
Pavilion Angle - 40,8
Crown % - 14,6
Lower Girdle % - 77,0
Culet- Pointed
Fluorescence - Negligible
Girdle - Thin to medium faceted
Light Performance - Ideal
Polish - Ideal
Symmetry - Ideal

3) Round, 1.302, I color, VS2, Ideal.
Depth % - 60,6
Table % - 57,4
Crown Angle - 33,0
Star - 52,0
Pavilion Angle - 41,0
Crown % - 13,8
Lower Girdle % - 78,0
Culet- Pointed
Fluorescence - Negligible
Girdle - Thin to medium
Light Performance - Ideal
Polish - Ideal
Symmetry - Ideal

Out of the three please let me know what is the best. Thanks!

 

[iluvdiamonds2]

Gee I'd love to help, but I"m no gemologist. I would get the biggest one - what are the measurements?
What if u did SI1 instead of the others and went to H?

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Yes, you left off the diameter measurements, and that will likely show you why a stone like #1 is not a good option. What is your budget and does the upgrade have to come from a particular vendor?

 

[Steffiem]

Sorry for leaving out the measurements But thanks for the replies so far!

Diamond number 1: 7.25-7.29X4.56

Diamond number 2: 7.05-7.08X4.31

Diamond number 3: 7.04-7.09x4.29

I am fine with going with any of the top online vendors. Ideally I would like to upgrade to a 1,3 (1,5 would be great but kinda out of my budget right now). My budget is $9000 max $9500 (I know this is a low budget right now, the three above are in my price range but I am really skeptical about the of diamond number one since it is not far off price wise from the other two which are smaller). I currently have an I color so I am fine with getting another I.

 

[Steffiem]

Diamond No.1 is now out of the question - it just sold out...