Please help! Three diamonds, which one is best?

[B1gglesw0rth]

Hello there, I posted the other day about HCA scores and got some great feedback and guidance from diamondseeker2006 and others on here. Now I'm back as we've narrowed it down to three options that are very similar and we're torn! Hoping you will weigh in and help ease our minds in making this decision (we've been looking at diamonds for so long I think we're starting to go crazy!).

Option 1
1.13
G
VVS2
table 55%
crown angle 34.5
pavilion 41
6.72 x 6.70 x 4.16
$11,131 CAD
HCA 1.8

Option 2
1.15
G
VS2
table 57%
crown angle 35
pavilion angle 40.8
6.74 x 6.77 x 4.15
$11,373
HCA 1.6

Option 3
1.18
G
VVS1
table 56%
crown angle 35
pavilion 40.8
6.77 x 6.76 x 4.20
$11,425
HCA 1.6

The winner seems to be the 1.18 but it's also the most expensive. Are the other two far behind? Or which one stands out to you?

Thanks in advance!

 

[OoohShiny]

I'm not sure what the crown angle is that means the pavilion angle has to drop to 40.6 in order to perform the best it can - the HCA scores show promise but you need someone with more knowledge than me to comment.

I think @rockysalamander might be able to assist