Please help me decide which is better

[jstandra]

Please help me choose between these 2 diamonds

First diamond:

GIA Round Brilliant
6.53-6.55 X 3.94 mm
1.02 carat
E color
VVS2 clarity
excellent cut grade
excellent polish & symmetry
Fluorecense: None
Griddle: Medium (Faceted)
Price: $10,500

Second diamond:
AGS Round Diamond
6.6-6.65 X 4.03 mm
1.07 carat
E color
VVS2 clarity
Ideal cut grade
Ideal polish & symmetry
Fluorecense: Neglible
Price: $9,970

Both diamonds score 0.9 at HCA

Both diamonds are not from the same vendor. Please let me know how do you think which one I should choose.

Thank you very much for your help

 

[JulieN]

second diamond is bigger and cheaper.

 

[jstandra]

that is what I''m thinking as well but the 2nd diamond has neglible fluorecense which mean that it has slightly blue color if I''m not mistaken

 

[JulieN]

GIA none and AGS negligible are equivalent.

 

[jstandra]

Thank you for the information, more opinions would be very appreciated

 

[bosoxbw]

Based on the numbers and prices you provided, I would pick #2.

However, why so high on color/clarity? You could drop at least to an F/VS2 without any noticeable difference, and either get a bigger stone or spend some money.

 

[jstandra]

Thank you for the suggestions, I''ll do some research further whether it''ll be better to go bigger but lower quality or go with the way it is right now.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Even if it had medium florescence, you probably wouldn''t see it unless you put the diamond under a black light. Bu as someone said, negligible bascially means none so it is not an issue. I''d choose the second one assuming the girdle is in the range of thin-medium-slightly thick.