Please help me choose one princess cut diamond

[xiaonanelsa]

There are two princess cut diamonds. I'm not sure which one to choose....the are soooo similar except for the clarity. Please help me choose one......it's really hard to decide......I've listed them as follows:

#1:$12553.00

6.51 x 6.42 x 4.62
1.51ct
E VS2
Polish excellent
symmetry very good
table 74%
depth 72.0%
medium
only very few feather crystal pinpoint listed on GIA,
but all on the corner

#2 price: $13320.00

6.59 x 6.44 x 4.55
1.51ct
E VVS2
Polish very good
symmetry good
table 76%
depth 70.6%
medium to slightly thick
only very few feather listed on GIA,
but all on the corner

 

[kenny]

GIA does not grade cut on Princess diamonds.
AGS does so I'd shop for one that got an AGS 0 cut grade.

I'd also get ASET scope images, or better yet buy an ASET scope and slowly rock the diamond under the scope in person looking for the one that looks best over the largest angle change.

http://www.ideal-scope.com/1.using_ASET_scope.asp

 

[xiaonanelsa]

Thanks Kenny...but they are on JA and Bluenile...Not sure whether they can do AGS?

 

[kenny]

Thanks Kenny...but they are on JA and Bluenile...Not sure whether they can do AGS?

Then, I would not consider those stones.
If those vendors carry NO princess cuts graded by AGS I'd find another vendor.
There are several good ones.

Good cut is more important than color or clarity to the beauty of a diamond.
AGS 0 grade and reflector tools like ASET can help you pick a well cut Princess cut.
You can also opt for a branded Princess cut like ACA from Whiteflash or Cut by Infinity by High Performance Diamonds.

Also I added ASET info to my above post.

 

[slg47]

do you have the link to the JA one? JA provides images and can also provide ASET images.

 

[xiaonanelsa]

Great！ Thanks! I'll ask the JA agent to send me one....