Please help evaluate this stone

[girl friday]

I'm considering this stone as part of a pair of diamond studs. The HCA score = 2.6, but I know that's only a guideline, so I'm wondering if I should eliminate it based on that, or if there's more to it that I, as a novice, can't see. Here are the stats:

Round brilliant
Cut = GIA excellent
Polish = ex
Symmetry = ex
Depth = 61.4
Table = 57
Girdle = Thin to medium
Crown angle = 35.5
crown height: 15.5%
Pavilion angle = 40.8
pavilion depth = 43.0%
clarity = VS2
Fluorescence = none
Girdle = thin to medium
Color I
measures 5.99x6.03x3.69

What do you think? Will it be fiery and sparkly or not so much?
Thank you!

 

[Dancing Fire]

Date: 4/26/2010 1:51:58 AM
Author:girl friday
I''m considering this stone as part of a pair of diamond studs. The HCA score = 2.6, but I know that''s only a guideline, so I''m wondering if I should eliminate it based on that, or if there''s more to it that I, as a novice, can''t see. Here are the stats:

Round brilliant
Cut = GIA excellent
Polish = ex
Symmetry = ex
Depth = 61.4
Table = 57
Girdle = Thin to medium
Crown angle = 35.5
crown height: 15.5%
Pavilion angle = 40
pavilion depth = 43.0%
clarity = VS2
Fluorescence = none
Girdle = thin to medium
Color I
measures 5.99x6.03x3.69

What do you think? Will it be fiery and sparkly or not so much?
Thank you!

think you are missing something there.

maybe more like 40.7 or 40.8?

 

[girl friday]

Whoops...the pavilion angle is 40.8.

I will edit the original post accordingly.

*Sigh* I''m new. Can you tell?!?

 

[stone-cold11]

borderline, Idealscope image will tell more, can you get it?

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 4/26/2010 4:14:42 AM
Author: Stone-cold11
borderline, Idealscope image will tell more, can you get it?

Hi GF

Stone is right, the diamond is borderline as the angles are hovering around what we call '' steep deep,'' possibility of light leakage, hence an Idealscope image will tell us more.