Please help! Comments on these diamonds

[FancyDiamond]

I am considering these diamonds. Which one has the most potential?

Diamond #1
GIA spec
Ex cut
VG polish
EX symmetry
60.1% depth
57% table,
34 crown
40.6 pavilion
55% star
80% lower half
thin to medium 3.0% girdle
HCA 0.6 Ex Ex Ex Ex

Diamond #2
GIA spec
Ex cut
VG polish
VG symmetry
60.5% depth
56% table,
34 crown
40.8 pavilion
55% star
75% lower half
thin to medium 2.5% girdle
HCA 0.8 Ex Ex Ex Ex

Diamond #3
GIA spec
Ex cut
VG polish
EX symmetry
60.7% depth
56% table,
35 crown
40.6 pavilion
45% star
75% lower half
medium to sl thick 3.5% girdle
HCA 0.8 Ex Ex Ex VG

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 10/13/2009 2:34:36 PM
Author:FancyDiamond
I am considering these diamonds. Which one has the most potential?

Diamond #1
GIA spec
Ex cut
VG polish
EX symmetry
60.1% depth
57% table,
34 crown
40.6 pavilion
55% star
80% lower half
thin to medium 3.0% girdle
HCA 0.6 Ex Ex Ex Ex

Diamond #2
GIA spec
Ex cut
VG polish
VG symmetry
60.5% depth
56% table,
34 crown
40.8 pavilion
55% star
75% lower half
thin to medium 2.5% girdle
HCA 0.8 Ex Ex Ex Ex

Diamond #3
GIA spec
Ex cut
VG polish
EX symmetry
60.7% depth
56% table,
35 crown
40.6 pavilion
45% star
75% lower half
medium to sl thick 3.5% girdle
HCA 0.8 Ex Ex Ex VG

They all have potential but from the info we have I would lean towards 2 as my first choice and 3 possibly, do you have the usual Idealscope images Fancy? An image for #3 would be useful to check that one out carefully due to the star percentage. Number 1 could be a good diamond also if an Idealscope image checks out with that angle combo.

 

[stone-cold11]

All looks good from the number but #2 seems safest for me.

IS images?

 

[FancyDiamond]

Thank you for helping. This is the first round of shopping, and I do not have the IS.

OK. #2 is a keeper for now. I need 4 more. How do these look?

Diamond #4
GIA spec
Ex cut
Ex polish
Ex symmetry
61.5% depth
57% table,
34 crown
40.8 pavilion
med to sl thk 4% girdle
60% star
75% lower half
HCA = 1.1
Ex Ex Ex VG

Diamond #5
GIA spec
Ex cut
VG polish
VG symmetry
60.5% depth
58% table,
33.5 crown
41 pavilion
thin to med 3.5% girdle
50% star
80% lower half
HCA = 1.0
Ex Ex Ex Ex

Diamond #6
GIA spec
Ex cut
Ex polish
Ex symmetry
61.6% depth
56% table,
34 crown
40.8 pavilion
thin to sl thk 3.5% girdle
55% star
75% lower half
HCA = 1.0
Ex Ex Ex VG

Diamond #7
GIA spec
Ex cut
VG polish
VG symmetry
60.9% depth
55% table,
33.5 crown
41 pavilion
thin to sl thick 2.5% girdle
50% star
80% lower half
HCA = 0.9
Ex Ex Ex EX

 

[stone-cold11]

All look promising from the numbers.