please help choosing between these 4 diamonds

[finallyready]

1.5cts EGL Certified
H, VS2
7.24 - 7.17 x 4.57
Table Depth 63.4%
Table Width 57% Price: 8600
crown height 15%
pavilion 43%
girdle - medium, faceted
Polish and Sym are both VG
Fluorescence: very slight blue
Diamond Cut Analysis score: 1.9
Light - Ex
Fire - Ex
Scint - Ex
Spread- Good
-----------------------------------
1.53cts EGL Certified
H, VS2
7.42 - 7.35 x 4.58
Table Depth 62%
Table Width 55% price: 8600
crown height 15%
pavilion 43%
girdle - medium, faceted
Polish and Sym are both excellent
Fluorescence: moderate blue
Diamond Cut Analysis score: 0.9
Light - Ex
Fire - Ex
Scint - Ex
Spread- Very Good
---------------------------------------------
1.64cts EGL Certified
H, VS2
7.66 - 7.64 x 4.57 Price: 9400
Table Depth 59.7%
Table Width 59%
crown height 13%
pavilion 43%
girdle - medium, faceted
Polish and Sym are both VG
Fluorescence: none
Diamond Cut Analysis score: 1.3
Light - VG
Fire - Ex
Scint - Ex
Spread- Ex
-------------------------------------------

http://www.jamesallen.com/diamonds/I-SI1-Ideal-Cut-Round-Diamond-1290398.asp

 

[yssie]

Request an IS for the JA - #4

 

[stone-cold11]

ditto.

 

[Lorelei]

The JA diamond has potential, do check that the grade setting clouds aren''t impacting performance by asking one of the gemologists to check and that the diamond is eyeclean to your standards.