Pink vs Yellow tint to H diamond? Which is better?

[Julie Williams 123452725]

I’m curious which diamond is a better choice,
Both H, Ideal, VS1, 1.35 carats.
The left seems to have more of a pink hue, where the right seems to be a bit more yellow?
It will be placed in a rose gold band.
Thanks for the feedback!

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Can you please post the grading reports on the two stones? That way we can evaluate if one is cut better than the other. The one on the left may have a slight brown undertone.

 

[Julie Williams 123452725]

Can you please post the grading reports on the two stones? That way we can evaluate if one is cut better than the other. The one on the left may have a slight brown undertone.

The 1.32 is the one that appears a bit pink to me from the side.

 

[musicloveranthony]

I prefer tones other than yellow. I like faint brown. Faint pink is nice, too

 

[MamaBee]

I’m also a faint brown and pink undertone lover too. I don’t like yellow undertones. I hope the pink one wins.

 

[YadaYadaYada]

I wonder if that pink is going to be noticeable IRL. I also have a CVD diamond but it is a K Faint Brown. Without the faint brown designation I probably wouldn’t see the pink. Even with the faint brown it’s only apparent in certain lighting.

All that to say that this might not show enough pink IRL, just don’t want you to be disappointed by the potential for it to face up pretty white.

 

[YadaYadaYada]

Here is a visual, the top is as pink as it gets, granted a rose gold setting would help elevate that hint of color more. You wouldn’t even know it ever looks pink from the bottom pic

 

[Alybetter]

I prefer a pink undertone over yellow.

 

[margauxmines]

I would never pass up a pink undertone unless it was much more poorly cut than the other option.

 

[monipod]

They're not small stones but I don't think the slight tint will be noticeable once set. If you're setting in rose gold though, I'd choose the pink/brown tinted stone as you might get nice hints of pinks in some light that way.

 

[oncrutchesrightnow]

Agree that your eyes are not fooling you… the one on the left is pink/brown compared to the one on the right. I would pick that one regardless of the setting but think the rose gold would look great.