Pick One!

[GarGan]

GIA CERT
1.0 Princess cut diamond
color=F
clarity=VS2
Depth=72.2
Table=62.0
girdle= thin-med
price= $4300

or

GIA CERT
1.0 Princess cut diamond
color=E
clarity=VS2
depth=70.9
table=67.0
girdle= slightly thick to thick
price=$4600

Just trying to get an idea..

 

[fuffi]

Both probably have good potential. The table sizes and depths look really good. I would go with the one that looks best to you visually. Also make sure the crown has good height and the stone doesn't look too flat.