oval opinions please

[reds]

Buying a 2.17 oval
Gia Cert
si1 G color
10.35 x 6.61 x 4.5
Depth 67.6
table 58
Girdle- medium to thick
Polish/sym Very good/good
culet- none
fluorescence none

Will take to independent appraiser whenI finally receive it but wanted unofficial opinions please. Thanks reds

 

[oldminer]

It may have a pleasing outline, but it is a little deep. This along with the thick girdle will adversly reduce a little brilliancy and will make this diamond not look as large as others with a little less depth. Diamonds a bit less deep have a larger length and/or width and that is what the eye sees, not the depth, when a diamond is being worn.

The price may reflect this cutting and the value and appearance may look perfect to you. That's fine and it all may work out great. Opinions without seeing the stone will vary more than ones from direct observation.