Opinions on these for 1''st timer

[davis2nd]

New to this board and recently started shopping for diamonds, given the knowledge everyone here has I would like your opinions on three diamonds I have found at a local jeweler. Thanks again.

All are princess cuts

Option A:

1.06 ct
J
VS2
Polish= Very Good
Sym= Good
$3485

Option B:

1.00 ct
H
VVS2
Polish= Excellent
Sym= Very Good
$4200

Option C:

1.20 ct
J
VVS2
Poilsh= Very Good
Sym= Very Good
$4485


I know pics would be nice, but they all look beautiful.
Thanks again for all opinions.

 

[Ellen]

Hi davis,

There''s not near enough info as far as numbers to make any kind of real recommendation. Personally, I would rule out the first for only Good Symmetry, although you''ve seen it, and may not have noticed a diifference? And VVS is more than I would personally pay for.


Since you have seen them, I''d say pick the one your eyes like best, if you are wanting one of these 3.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Do these have GIA lab reports or another kind? What are the crown and pavilion angles? We''d need to know that to be able to tell you which ones are the better cut.

 

[Lorelei]

Welcome!

As you have seen these diamonds, then which one do you like best? With PC''s we really need depth and table and photographs if available to be able to help, but you have the advantage in seeing them, so trust your eyes! You could drop your clarity from VVS and still have a very clean diamond, but this is a personal preference!