Opinion please...

[Michael Prager]

D VS1 with med. blue fluorescence o E VS1 with no fluorescence? Everything else being equal? Thanks!

 

[lovedogs]

Are the diamonds literally equal in every other way (proportions, etc)? Unfortunately, we can't really speak to this without more info.

 

[Michael Prager]

Are the diamonds literally equal in every other way (proportions, etc)? Unfortunately, we can't really speak to this without more info.

Yes, everything else is almost exactly the same. Thanks again!

 

[lovedogs]

GIA certificates? Price is identical? Do you have pictures?

 

[Michael Prager]

Sorry no pics but the D VS1 is quite a bit cheaper.

 

[musicloveranthony]

If (and only if) they were otherwise identical - like down to the minute angles - I wouldn't care either way. I'd choose the cheaper option

 

[Kaycee2018]

I’d want to see copies of the lab reports before deciding. VS1 is totally safe, but I’d want to compare inclusions. Also, I’d be very surprised if all the proportions for both stones are exactly the same. It’s not impossible, but highly unlikely.

 

[MamaBear]

Color and clarity really don’t matter much until the cut is verified. Can you post reports?

 

[diamondseeker2006]

If both diamonds were perfectly cut, then I'd for sure go with the D VS1 that costs less. I'd be thrilled with the fluorescence and lower price!

I hope you have seen photos and/or videos of the two stones. We would never recommend buying a diamond without those at the very minimum. That's why people are asking you for the grading reports to be sure these stones are in the ideal cut range. That's the starting point.