Opinion on this GIA Cert Stone

[berkefamily2]

Cushion

1.74 ct weight

8.23X7.28x3.94

Table 70%
Depth 54.1%
Polish good
Symmetry very good
Slightly thick- Thick girdle
Cutlet none.


I know this is not a lot but how can the dimensions be so big on the this stone? This is a private party sale from an engagement breakup.

 

[SeaOats]

Because of the very shallow depth of 54%.

 

[rosey610]

Way off cut.