Opinion on these two diamonds?

[winterbaby520]

Hi,
Any feedback on these two diamonds is greatly appreciated!

Diamond 1:
GIA triple Excellent, no Floresence
7.44 - 7.46 x 4.65 mm; I; VS1
Table: 56%
Depth: 62.4
Crown: 35.5
Pavilion: 40.6
HCA Score: 1.4 (Ex, Ex, Ex, VG)



Diamond 2:
GIA triple excellent
Medium Floresence
7.54 x 7.49 x 4.70 mm; I; VS2
Table: 57%
Depth: 62.5
Crown: 35.5
Pavilion: 40.8
HCA Score: 2.7 (VG, VG, VG, VG)


I have also attached images of them here.
Now obviously Diamond 1 has a much better HCA score. But I'm concered with all the light red around the center. With such a high HCA score, there seems to be a lot of light leakage?

Diamond 2 has a lower HCA score, but the ideal scope image looks better to me??

This is my first time reading images, so I can be completely wrong. Any help is appreciated!

Thanks!