Opinion on diamond setting design (Pics)

[rubilee]

Hi all!
So my boyfriend and I just bought a beautiful 2.5+ carat warm N colored stone that has gorgeous symmetry and a wonderful cushiony rounded square shape. When I set out looking for diamonds I thought I was going to go for an OEC but my boyfriend fell in love with the way OMCs looked and looking more into it I loved how unique each OMC is from one to the next. initially I wanted a setting based on the shape of one I had tried on due to its simple clean lines and architectural take on the cathedral setting. I also wanted some details added from another ring I’ve tried on in the past. However, I guess now I’m rethinking whether this will suit the shape of my OMC as a lot of these ideas were centered around getting an OEC. I’ve been gravitating towards how beautifully a solitaire could bring out the squared shape of my OMC. And the squarish shape really complements my long thin fingers. Would love to get the opinions of this forum! I can almost see hints of like a pinkish/champagne color in the diamond and I’ve been playing around with the idea of a rose gold basket with a gold band (gold suits me) vs a gold band and white basket which I can’t do with the design I originally had in mind Bc the shank turns into the prongs. Included are pictures of my diamond and the rings I wanted to take elements of for my ring. Namely prong positioning of the platinum ring while simplifying the side view so the yellow leaves aren’t there anymore kind of just leaving the “A” in place in the gold ring as well as taking away the muligrain to make the ring look more streamlined. Will update once I get cad designs too. But I really am going back and forth about the solitaire idea. Would love the opinions of this forum!

 

[rubilee]

Hi all!
So my boyfriend and I just bought a beautiful 2.5+ carat warm N colored stone that has gorgeous symmetry and a wonderful cushiony rounded square shape. When I set out looking for diamonds I thought I was going to go for an OEC but my boyfriend fell in love with the way OMCs looked and looking more into it I loved how unique each OMC is from one to the next. initially I wanted a setting based on the shape of one I had tried on due to its simple clean lines and architectural take on the cathedral setting. I also wanted some details added from another ring I’ve tried on in the past. However, I guess now I’m rethinking whether this will suit the shape of my OMC as a lot of these ideas were centered around getting an OEC. I’ve been gravitating towards how beautifully a solitaire could bring out the squared shape of my OMC. And the squarish shape really complements my long thin fingers. Would love to get the opinions of this forum! I can almost see hints of like a pinkish/champagne color in the diamond and I’ve been playing around with the idea of a rose gold basket with a gold band (gold suits me) vs a gold band and white basket which I can’t do with the design I originally had in mind Bc the shank turns into the prongs. Included are pictures of my diamond and the rings I wanted to take elements of for my ring. Namely prong positioning of the platinum ring while simplifying the side view so the yellow leaves aren’t there anymore kind of just leaving the “A” in place in the gold ring as well as taking away the muligrain to make the ring look more streamlined. Will update once I get cad designs too. But I really am going back and forth about the solitaire idea. Would love the opinions of this forum!

Bump?

 

[catcav]

You have a beautiful diamond! I do not know much about oec. I just upgraded to a new WF ACA. I know I want a different setting, Like to match my eternity wedding band or even a three stone wrap, but for now, I set it as a solitaire bc ultimately that is my fav setting. I will enjoy it set on its own and let it speak to me about its ultimate setting. That’s my advice. Solitaire to start

 

[Sabrina31]

I love the second option, and think the rose gold basket could work but it would need to be done just right. Are you shopping for a custom ring or an in-stock setting?

 

[rubilee]

I love the second option, and think the rose gold basket could work but it would need to be done just right. Are you shopping for a custom ring or an in-stock setting?

I’m in the process of design a custom setting now. I think with the current ring design I’m pursuing, since the shank and prongs are one piece of metal, I don’t know how there would be a rose gold basket since there’s no separate basket per say. However with a more classic solitaire I would be able to have a rose gold basket with a gold band. I keep wondering if I’m going to regret not going for a more unique band though if I go the solitaire route. *sigh*

 

[lulu_ma]

Beautiful diamond! Do you know what kind of wedding band style you want? That may help you decide on a perfect engagement ring setting.

 

[rubilee]

Beautiful diamond! Do you know what kind of wedding band style you want? That may help you decide on a perfect engagement ring setting.

I think it’s probably going to be a simple thin band in a contrasting metal to whatever the ring is

 

[kgizo]

I think your inspiration ring would work well with an OMC. Does the designer you are working with have any advice about a two tone metal look?

 

[rubilee]

I think your inspiration ring would work well with an OMC. Does the designer you are working with have any advice about a two tone metal look?

The jeweler and I discussed a two tone metal look and he said he would discuss it with the CAD artist, but ultimately, I think that inspiration rings I have in mind are both made of a single piece of metal with no separate prongs

 

[rubilee]

So I got the CAD design. I am going to ask that the cutouts are half circles instead of leaves and repositioning of the prongs if possible so they are all East-west/split shank rather than north-south-East-west. I’m also going to go for a single tone 18k gold or rose gold setting as I think the two tone just isn’t the look I’m going for. I’m also asking for more delicate claw like prongs. My primary concern is an overly flowery design. I want something unique and with a modern flair but that faintly reminds one of the past. Something architectural with clean lines and elegance that puts the diamond at center focus and brings out the shape and color of this specific diamond. I really like the cathedral setting so I’m really asking for a cathedral setting with the shank work of the setting proposed belowAnyone have any input or feedback?

 

[maryjane04]

I think there's an in between apricot gold.. which is a softer rose/yellow blend. My ring is that colour which you wouldn't know unless you were comparing it against a yellow gold item. My prongs are white gold. I think it's achievable depending on what you want!

 

[tyty333]

What do you plan on putting on the sides where the North/South prongs currently are?

Can you draw pictures of how you think the sides will be where you want the cathedral shank and what you want on
the North/south sides?

Edit...I think some of the things you are saying wont work together (at least I cant picture it in my head).

- make cut out circles but, that area is going to have prongs going through it now so there wont be space/area for circles?
- change prongs to be at 2, 4, 8, 10 but
- you want a cathedral shank? Where is the cathedral going to connect up to in the gallery area?

 

[rubilee]

so I understand the “w” will be narrower on side view of the ring with these adjustments which I’m okay with

What do you plan on putting on the sides where the North/South prongs currently are?

Can you draw pictures of how you think the sides will be where you want the cathedral shank and what you want on
the North/south sides?

Edit...I think some of the things you are saying wont work together (at least I cant picture it in my head).

- make cut out circles but, that area is going to have prongs going through it now so there wont be space/area for circles?
- change prongs to be at 2, 4, 8, 10 but
- you want a cathedral shank? Where is the cathedral going to connect up to in the gallery area?

 

[rubilee]

I don’t know if I’m trying to change things too much? And mesh designs that don’t work? I like the shank work of the gold ring and the prong positioning of the platinum ring. Lol now I feel kind of lost and like I have no clue what I’m doing! Haalppp

 

[Cerulean]

so I understand the “w” will be narrower on side view of the ring with these adjustments which I’m okay with

To be honest? I am having a hard time envisioning the changes you’re asking for working (maybe I’m wrong) - you’re trying to merge two styles, and you are actually back to the first style you posted (almost) but not as aesthetically “smooth” IMO - keep in mind if you do pave on the sides it might tear up your wedding band

 

[rubilee]

New CADS! Thinking of making the profile more concave as the shanks become the prongs and shortening the pave so it ends earlier on the ring. Any other opinions? Any concern about how secure the diamond will be or suggestions on making it more secure?

 

[lovedogs]

Obviously if you love it then that's all that matters. But I think this new CAD looks unusual to me. It's like trying to mix architectural and vintage together, which doesn't work IMHO. Definitely not trying to be rude, just want to give honest feedback.

 

[tyty333]

I'm not sure if I'm a good one to help anymore.

I don't like it. It looks very off-balanced to me, I don't like the "prongs" and don't like the way it looks from the sides
(the full shank or the side of the shank). Really, nothing I like about it so, if you like this new iteration, I'll just bow out.

Edit...I sincerely do wish you the best in getting to the design that you love and I hope that someone else "gets" your vision
and can help!

 

[lovedogs]

If you hate this then feel free to ignore me. But what if you kept the "top down" view the same as your first original inspo pic (split prongs, etc), and then did this with the side view (e.g. the black = cut outs)? that way it's not SO open from the side (which I think is my issue with the current CAD), and still overall has a vintage vibe without look disjointed.

 

[Cerulean]

Can you work with a designer to help you bring your vision to life? Is there anyone who’s designs you liked?

It seems like the designer you are working with now is giving you full design control, which is good when you know what you are doing (which most people don’t, myself included) and really hard if you aren’t a designer.

I don’t think any of us mean to be rude, we just want you to get something you love. Hope this comes off as well intended and not offensive. I love the two inspiration rings, just not the way their features are meshing together

 

[Mrs Flowers]

All that matters is if YOU like it. I’m my opinion it looks too bulky , too busy, there is way too much going on. I feel like the main gorgeous diamond gets lost and forgotten and it needs to shine. I feel like it’s many different styles all put together. I mean this in the nicest possible way. Just giving my honest opinion here. I really like the original design you posted the very first picture. This one !

 

[Sabrina31]

I'm concerned about how tall the latest cad has the diamond sitting, that looks like it will be really tall coming off your hand. I love @lovedogs idea above in the rose gold, when I look at the way it currently is I don't see the w in the gallery if that makes sense? We're going to support you and be happy for you either way but I dont think you've quite hit the nail on the head yet

 

[rubilee]

I wanted to post my final ring here too for closure! Thank you for all of the feedback everyone provided- Thank you so much for all your honest opinions. It looked awkward and even I couldn’t picture the final results. I ended up taking the design in a different direction. I don’t have pictures and have yet to receive the ring but I’m so thrilled with the final design! Below is a link to the video Adam posted to his Instagram of the final ring!

Login • Instagram

Welcome back to Instagram. Sign in to check out what your friends, family & interests have been capturing & sharing around the world.

www.instagram.com

 

[Cerulean]

I wanted to post my final ring here too for closure! Thank you for all of the feedback everyone provided- Thank you so much for all your honest opinions. It looked awkward and even I couldn’t picture the final results. I ended up taking the design in a different direction. I don’t have pictures and have yet to receive the ring but I’m so thrilled with the final design! Below is a link to the video Adam posted to his Instagram of the final ring!

Login • Instagram

Welcome back to Instagram. Sign in to check out what your friends, family & interests have been capturing & sharing around the world.

www.instagram.com

The end result is stunning! Congratulations

 

[Mrs Flowers]

The end result is stunning! Congratulations

Love it!!! That’s much much better than the original. It came out great.

 

[Lookinagain]

Much better! It's beautiful. Glad you went in another direction because it definitely works! Congrats.

 

[lulu_ma]

Congrats! Looks gorgeous. Can’t wait for a hand shot

 

[MamaBear]

Gorgeous! Im glad you got to your happy setting in the end!

 

[tyty333]

It turned out very nice! Congratulations!

 

[nutellakitty]

Hi all!
So my boyfriend and I just bought a beautiful 2.5+ carat warm N colored stone that has gorgeous symmetry and a wonderful cushiony rounded square shape. When I set out looking for diamonds I thought I was going to go for an OEC but my boyfriend fell in love with the way OMCs looked and looking more into it I loved how unique each OMC is from one to the next. initially I wanted a setting based on the shape of one I had tried on due to its simple clean lines and architectural take on the cathedral setting. I also wanted some details added from another ring I’ve tried on in the past. However, I guess now I’m rethinking whether this will suit the shape of my OMC as a lot of these ideas were centered around getting an OEC. I’ve been gravitating towards how beautifully a solitaire could bring out the squared shape of my OMC. And the squarish shape really complements my long thin fingers. Would love to get the opinions of this forum! I can almost see hints of like a pinkish/champagne color in the diamond and I’ve been playing around with the idea of a rose gold basket with a gold band (gold suits me) vs a gold band and white basket which I can’t do with the design I originally had in mind Bc the shank turns into the prongs. Included are pictures of my diamond and the rings I wanted to take elements of for my ring. Namely prong positioning of the platinum ring while simplifying the side view so the yellow leaves aren’t there anymore kind of just leaving the “A” in place in the gold ring as well as taking away the muligrain to make the ring look more streamlined. Will update once I get cad designs too. But I really am going back and forth about the solitaire idea. Would love the opinions of this forum!

Hi @rubilee . I fell in love with the last yellow gold setting. Do you have a front picture of that?

Thank you!