Ok, help me pick between these three!

[RamsInfiniti]

Alright all, I need to make a decision ASAP on this, so please help me. Here are three diamonds with their specs, assuming they are all roughly the same price, which do you think would be my best bet:

D color, VS2, 1.19 carats, Ex/Ex/Ex
57% table, 61.6% depth, 35.5 crown, 40.8 pavillion
one crystal off to the side

E color, VS2, 1.23 carats, Ex/Ex/Ex
56% table, 62% depth, 35.0 crown, 40.6 pavillion
slightly off center cloud, one I.N.

E color, VS2, 1.28 carats, Ex/Ex/Ex
58% table, 62.1% depth, 35.0 crown, 41.0 pavillion
several small clouds

Any opinions would be greatly appreciated! Thanks!

James

 

[stone-cold11]

#2 gets my vote.

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 2/25/2009 12:03:02 PM
Author:RamsInfiniti
Alright all, I need to make a decision ASAP on this, so please help me. Here are three diamonds with their specs, assuming they are all roughly the same price, which do you think would be my best bet:

D color, VS2, 1.19 carats, Ex/Ex/Ex
57% table, 61.6% depth, 35.5 crown, 40.8 pavillion
one crystal off to the side

E color, VS2, 1.23 carats, Ex/Ex/Ex
56% table, 62% depth, 35.0 crown, 40.6 pavillion
slightly off center cloud, one I.N.

E color, VS2, 1.28 carats, Ex/Ex/Ex
58% table, 62.1% depth, 35.0 crown, 41.0 pavillion
several small clouds

Any opinions would be greatly appreciated! Thanks!

James

2 looks the safest, if you could get an ASET image for the first and third then we can evaluate those further James.

 

[Ellen]

3 votes for 2.

 

[RamsInfiniti]

Thanks everybody. It''s the one I currently have on hold, and it scores a 0.9 on the HCA.

I think I will pull the trigger

 

[Kelli]

2!