I''m in a dilemma right now. For my engagement ring, my fiance gave me his late mother''s wedding ring, which has a center diamond originally from his grandmother''s wedding ring in Bezel setting. It, of course, has high sentimental value to him. We then went to a jeweler and pick out a new setting so we could transfer the diamond from his late mother''s wedding ring onto the new ring. When the jeweler removed the diamond and examined it, it was discovered that the quality of the diamond is pretty poor with many inclusions and imperfections visible to the eye (clarity ~ I1 or I2). Because it was originally set in the bezel setting, those inclusions and imperfections were not as visible. Now, my new ring is in four prong setting, these inclusions are more visible to the naked eye. I really want a diamond with much better quality (at least eye clean) but I also know that this diamond means a lot to my fiance. When I told him that the diamond has a lot of visible inclusions, he didn''t offer to buy a new diamond (which he originally suggested as an option when he proposed - that I can take the diamond or he would buy a new one). Now, I''m not sure what I should do. I want to be happy with my e-ring but I don''t know if I should just simply keep the diamond or insist on getting a new diamond.