Newbie - Help me choose oval lab-grown diamond please!!

[de_priss]

Hello everyone!

I am a new member and I would highly appreciate your comments and piece of advice.

I am looking for an oval lab-grown diamond (both IGI certified) for an engagement ring and I torm between these two options:

Option #1. (HPHT, Type 2=II)

0.82 carat
7.49 mm x 5.43 xx 3.19
Color E
Clarity VS2
Fluoresence None
Polish/Symmetry EX/EX
Proportions: VG
Table: 61%, Depth 58.7%
Girlde: Med to Slightly Thick

Option #2. (CVD, type IIa)
0.81 carat
7.26 mm x 5.34 mm x 3.31 mm
Color G
Clarity VS1
Fluoresence None
Polish/Symmetry EX/EX
Proportions: VG
Table: 58%, Depth 62%
Girlde: Med to Thick

I lean towards the first, however even though it fits the "ideal" proportions I read online, when I plug it into diamdb.com it comes out as too shallow..

Any insight is more than welcome!!

 

[OoohShiny]

As tyty said in your original thread, put the stones on hold and post the videos because ovals can't be assessed from the numbers only.