TL|1381901882|3538617 said:So did anyone watch it? Any reviews?
I thought it was overly dramatized and a bit staged, but it was fun to watch something with gems in a television series.
iLander|1381928941|3538729 said:Oh, you all missed the wild inaccuracies and general BS!![]()
The guy went to Vietnam to find star rubies. Wouldn't Thailand or Tanzania be a better choice? But I let that go.
He said that "in a real star ruby, the star moves around. If it's fake, the start won't move around." I think ebay has a bunch of fakes with moving stars.
His goal was to find a "VERY large ruby so that he could cut it up into 4 smaller stones". If you found a large stone, wouldn't it be a travesty to cut it up? Wouldn't a cutter buy 4 smaller stones?
Then he purchased a bunch of tiny rubies, about 6-8 mm around, to facet. With rough yield averaging about 40%, wouldn't those end up as pave sized stones?
He was offered an "emerald" the size of my head that was obviously a dyed chunk of junk, and he had the sense to turn that down. The stuff he saw was all low-end stuff that I wouldn't even buy at a gem show.
They had a weird meter that I've never seen before. It had a large gauge with a needle that swung from "synthetic" to "genuine" and a probe attached. He just touched the probe to a stone and it would indicate real or fake. Is this what AGL has in the back room?![]()
He finally ended up finding a ping pong ball-sized stone (I think he paid $70000!) that was a pale, opaque mess and having that cut into 4 opaque, pale cabochons with very faint stars. The announcer proudly declared one of the cabochons (about 18 mm x 25 mm) was now worth $20,000! I've seen them at gem shows on the $10 table!
So, like most reality shows, it wasn't very real. But I can't wait until next week, when they go to Tanzania and feed the public more misinformation. It was entertaining to see a little of the country, and hear them says things like "We are flashing a huge wad of money, so people know we have money and bring out the good stones".![]()
I think as PSers, we should be ready for a lot of new posters with really awful stones that they think are worth thousands because of this show.![]()
I watched too, and thought it was incredibly disappointing. Other than enjoying the "journey" from hucksters, to sellers on the street, to the actual mine site (in which the host was so impressed to find a teeny bit of rough). I'll watch next week with hopes of having a different group of hosts, but if that's not the case I think I'll unprogram my dvr.iLander|1381928941|3538729 said:Oh, you all missed the wild inaccuracies and general BS!![]()
The guy went to Vietnam to find star rubies. Wouldn't Thailand or Tanzania be a better choice? But I let that go.
He said that "in a real star ruby, the star moves around. If it's fake, the start won't move around." I think ebay has a bunch of fakes with moving stars.
His goal was to find a "VERY large ruby so that he could cut it up into 4 smaller stones". If you found a large stone, wouldn't it be a travesty to cut it up? Wouldn't a cutter buy 4 smaller stones?
Then he purchased a bunch of tiny rubies, about 6-8 mm around, to facet. With rough yield averaging about 40%, wouldn't those end up as pave sized stones?
He was offered an "emerald" the size of my head that was obviously a dyed chunk of junk, and he had the sense to turn that down. The stuff he saw was all low-end stuff that I wouldn't even buy at a gem show.
They had a weird meter that I've never seen before. It had a large gauge with a needle that swung from "synthetic" to "genuine" and a probe attached. He just touched the probe to a stone and it would indicate real or fake. Is this what AGL has in the back room?![]()
He finally ended up finding a ping pong ball-sized stone (I think he paid $70000!) that was a pale, opaque mess and having that cut into 4 opaque, pale cabochons with very faint stars. The announcer proudly declared one of the cabochons (about 18 mm x 25 mm) was now worth $20,000! I've seen them at gem shows on the $10 table!
So, like most reality shows, it wasn't very real. But I can't wait until next week, when they go to Tanzania and feed the public more misinformation. It was entertaining to see a little of the country, and hear them says things like "We are flashing a huge wad of money, so people know we have money and bring out the good stones".![]()
I think as PSers, we should be ready for a lot of new posters with really awful stones that they think are worth thousands because of this show.![]()
iLander|1381935949|3538809 said:Chrono:![]()
![]()
I'm glad it gave you a smile.
My poor DH, I kept pausing the DVR to point out the errors and by the end of the show, I think DH was sick of hearing me squawk.
TL: Thanks for clarifying, I just googled the Presidium tester (that's is alright) and it specifically says on their site that it can't be used to judge between real and synthetic gemstones! Which is exactly what they used it for!Wow!
TL, didn't you have a link to the full first episode? Maybe post it here for those that missed it?
But I have to say, I'm not going to miss the next episode, it makes me feel so smart. Thanks to CS!
JewelFreak|1381959441|3539031 said:It's too bad. I'm disappointed it's such a load of bull. If they even bothered to use good gems it would be worth watching just to see them. I started snorting when the under-market sellers happily got on camera, with a police guy nearby, yet. I doubt it was really in N. Vietnam. I'll watch the next one, but if they come up with star sapphires where you can barely tell there is a star, like this one w/rubies, I'll pass from then on. I guess the 3 "gem hunters" are making a nice bundle, which is worth it for them -- and having a good laugh later.
Most likely. "Reality" television, ugh.TL said:or the sale is staged.
iLander|1381928941|3538729 said:Oh, you all missed the wild inaccuracies and general BS!![]()
The guy went to Vietnam to find star rubies. Wouldn't Thailand or Tanzania be a better choice? But I let that go.
He said that "in a real star ruby, the star moves around. If it's fake, the start won't move around." I think ebay has a bunch of fakes with moving stars.
His goal was to find a "VERY large ruby so that he could cut it up into 4 smaller stones". If you found a large stone, wouldn't it be a travesty to cut it up? Wouldn't a cutter buy 4 smaller stones?
Then he purchased a bunch of tiny rubies, about 6-8 mm around, to facet. With rough yield averaging about 40%, wouldn't those end up as pave sized stones?
He was offered an "emerald" the size of my head that was obviously a dyed chunk of junk, and he had the sense to turn that down. The stuff he saw was all low-end stuff that I wouldn't even buy at a gem show.
They had a weird meter that I've never seen before. It had a large gauge with a needle that swung from "synthetic" to "genuine" and a probe attached. He just touched the probe to a stone and it would indicate real or fake. Is this what AGL has in the back room?![]()
He finally ended up finding a ping pong ball-sized stone (I think he paid $70000!) that was a pale, opaque mess and having that cut into 4 opaque, pale cabochons with very faint stars. The announcer proudly declared one of the cabochons (about 18 mm x 25 mm) was now worth $20,000! I've seen them at gem shows on the $10 table!
So, like most reality shows, it wasn't very real. But I can't wait until next week, when they go to Tanzania and feed the public more misinformation. It was entertaining to see a little of the country, and hear them says things like "We are flashing a huge wad of money, so people know we have money and bring out the good stones".![]()
I think as PSers, we should be ready for a lot of new posters with really awful stones that they think are worth thousands because of this show.![]()