shape
carat
color
clarity

New Diamond Shopper - Need help!

ghdiamond

Rough_Rock
Joined
Jul 23, 2013
Messages
8
Hello everyone... Today was my first day of diamond shopping and had a budget of 15k with the ring and setting. I've decided that I was going to get my girl a round cut, 1.5 ct, G color, VS1, XXX, GIA cert. I was way off! Price was way over my budget.

After talking to a few dealers/jewelers, I was brought down to reality. I was shown a few diamonds;

1) A similar diamond I was originally looking for (way over my budget)

2) Similar specs as I was looking for but the carat size is around 1.3ish (at the budget)

3) 1.5, F color, SI2, XXX (under budget)

The thing that shocks me is the difference between #1 and #3 is the clarity. I've compared both side to side and I couldn't tell the difference except #3 looks a bit whiter. I really can't see the imperfections in number 3. I am really shocked about the price difference because of clarity.

My question is ...

1)Is it worth getting #3 or find a larger diamond and with a higher clarity rating to meet my budget?

Or

2) Get diamond #2... Sacrifice the size but get a higher quality stone.

Thank you.

G
 
SI2 is a big discount. if you find a nice one, it could be worth considering.

a G or H SI1 should be in your budget, though.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top