Hi everyone,
I've been reading this forum for last while and it gave me a confidence to search for the diamond online, so thank you all!
These are my first 2 picks hopefully you can give me some guidance please, the diamond is for an engagement ring by the way.
I think they both look good number wise, but 1.70 definitely has a better number.
Price is about the same, 16K.
2.1Ct is definitely larger, I value size a lot.
1.7 Ct's idealscope images looks great to me, maybe this is 60-60 diamond I read from this forum before.
James Allen provides idealscope picture but Bluenile won't so safer to purchase JA, however, both got good return policy so if I'm not happy with the stone I can always return.. can't decide!!
Which diamond would you personally choose, I can't decide!! or is there better option out there?
1.70 Ct SI1 Truehearts HCA 1.0 XXXX
http://www.jamesallen.com/loose-dia...-h-color-si1-clarity-excellent-cut-sku-267371
Depth 60%, Table 59%, Crown 34.0, Pavilion 40.6
Haven't heard back from gemologist yet but I think this looks eyeclean based on video
2.11 Ct SI1 Excellent cut Strongblue fluorescence HCA 1.8XXVV, BN says this diamond narrowly missed making Signature diamond
http://www.bluenile.com/ca/round-di...ty_LD04006558?tempcurr=CAD&click_id=634127524
Depth 62.1%, Table 56%, Crown 36.0, Pavilion 40.6
BN says this stone is eye-clean although the magnified picture shows lots of inclusion.
Also confirmed no negative fluorescence effects and no milkiness.
This is the photo BN provided, altho I see haziness at the bottom part of the picture, BN says it's just the light and angle of the photo taken.

Any opinion is welcome, thank you so much in advance!!
I've been reading this forum for last while and it gave me a confidence to search for the diamond online, so thank you all!
These are my first 2 picks hopefully you can give me some guidance please, the diamond is for an engagement ring by the way.
I think they both look good number wise, but 1.70 definitely has a better number.
Price is about the same, 16K.
2.1Ct is definitely larger, I value size a lot.
1.7 Ct's idealscope images looks great to me, maybe this is 60-60 diamond I read from this forum before.
James Allen provides idealscope picture but Bluenile won't so safer to purchase JA, however, both got good return policy so if I'm not happy with the stone I can always return.. can't decide!!
Which diamond would you personally choose, I can't decide!! or is there better option out there?
1.70 Ct SI1 Truehearts HCA 1.0 XXXX
http://www.jamesallen.com/loose-dia...-h-color-si1-clarity-excellent-cut-sku-267371
Depth 60%, Table 59%, Crown 34.0, Pavilion 40.6
Haven't heard back from gemologist yet but I think this looks eyeclean based on video
2.11 Ct SI1 Excellent cut Strongblue fluorescence HCA 1.8XXVV, BN says this diamond narrowly missed making Signature diamond
http://www.bluenile.com/ca/round-di...ty_LD04006558?tempcurr=CAD&click_id=634127524
Depth 62.1%, Table 56%, Crown 36.0, Pavilion 40.6
BN says this stone is eye-clean although the magnified picture shows lots of inclusion.
Also confirmed no negative fluorescence effects and no milkiness.
This is the photo BN provided, altho I see haziness at the bottom part of the picture, BN says it's just the light and angle of the photo taken.

Any opinion is welcome, thank you so much in advance!!