shape
carat
color
clarity

need honest opinions of a sapphire

What you guys think about Etsy sapphires? Some seem way too cheap so probably fake?
 
What you guys think about Etsy sapphires? Some seem way too cheap so probably fake?

Etsy is similar to ebay in that it is an online marketplace which has various sellers. So the quality will vary significantly depending on the listing. But there are certainly some high-end gems on there. Worth it to take a look!
 
beautiful, but says U.S. sales only and no returns so no go.

Too bad. I missed the US sales only. She has already dropped asking to $3750. Are you ever in NY? :mrgreen2:

 
Too bad. I missed the US sales only. She has already dropped asking to $3750. Are you ever in NY? :mrgreen2:


that is a beautiful gem! sadly way over my budget but hopefully someone else picks that up. thanks for sharing.
 
What you guys think of this stone? I got it on Etsy, comes with a lab certificate as being a padparadscha from Mozambique unheated, I find the color really pretty, though more red than pink/orange, but I just find it almost looks too perfect? Any thoughts? IMG20250715220850.jpgIMG20250715220658.jpg
 
What kind of certificate?

I really can’t tell from photos. It does look remarkably clean but then they are very clean sapphires around.
 
Here is the certificate...
sapphire cert.jpg
 
I would trust GFCO. I have quite a few stones with both Lotus and GFCO reports. They might differ on location and colour specifics but the basics are always correct. I like getting both reports on my higher value stones so that I can feel more comfortable relying on GFCO for my less expensive stones.
 
What you guys think of this stone? I got it on Etsy, comes with a lab certificate as being a padparadscha from Mozambique unheated, I find the color really pretty, though more red than pink/orange, but I just find it almost looks too perfect? Any thoughts? IMG20250715220850.jpgIMG20250715220658.jpg

I think there is a very large window. It would be easier to see if you put it between tweezers. I think you have somehow got to get your wife's opinion on stones with windows because for me, that is all I see. It ruins the entire stone for me.
 
What you guys think of this stone? I got it on Etsy, comes with a lab certificate as being a padparadscha from Mozambique unheated, I find the color really pretty, though more red than pink/orange, but I just find it almost looks too perfect? Any thoughts? IMG20250715220850.jpgIMG20250715220658.jpg

Again, this is all up for interpretation, but in my opinion, that is not a padparadscha by any stretch of the imagination. Now if you like the color, that's one thing. Congrats, admire him for what he is, and enjoy! But I'm confident that none of the major institutions would certify this stone as a pad. I've seen reports from this lab around, and I don't doubt they can probably decipher one gem from another, or a synthetic from a natural, or even basic heat, with relative ease. But certain treatments? I'm less confident. This stone may very well be untreated. But it could also be beryllium diffused (they abound in this particular shade), and that becomes tricky. This is because the process can introduce coloring agents deep into the stone, making the treatment harder to detect than with older, shallower diffusion methods. More advanced gemological techniques are required, such as LIBS. Now, in all honestly, I would be more worried about this if it said "heat only," because the method does require high heat, and that should be readily detectable. In any event, judging solely by what I'm seeing in your photos, this is a brownish-reddish-orange sapphire. And the color is very pretty! It's just not a pad (again, IMO). May I ask the weight and how much you paid?
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP

Featured Topics

Top