Need Help With Choosing 3ct Round

[zxcvbn16]

Hi all,

First post on here.... Need your expert views/opinions on choosing between these three diamonds for an engagement ring.... Am leaning towards either of the two >3ct options but are there strong pros/cons between the two? Both options score 0.9 on HCA and the 2.7 scored a 1.1... Also is I colour too yellow?!? Which one would you choose?

Much appreciated <3

Option 1 - 3.1ct WF ACA



Option 2 - 3.3ct James Allen


Option 3 - 2.7ct WF ACA

 

[MissGotRocks]

I would call Whiteflash and ask them to put those two diamonds side by side for you to look at their color. There is a size difference too so maybe that will help the decision making process. They would be more than happy to help you!

 

[tyty333]

Ditto @MissGotRocks . WF will do side-by-side pics for you.

Be sure to look at the trade-in/trade-up policies. Whiteflash has a much better trade-in policy if you decide you want to
go bigger or possibly change color etc.

The cut of the WF stones is also better. They are AGS000 (Ideal light return) H&A stones.

 

[zxcvbn16]

I would call Whiteflash and ask them to put those two diamonds side by side for you to look at their color. There is a size difference too so maybe that will help the decision making process. They would be more than happy to help you!

Ditto @MissGotRocks . WF will do side-by-side pics for you.

Be sure to look at the trade-in/trade-up policies. Whiteflash has a much better trade-in policy if you decide you want to
go bigger or possibly change color etc.

The cut of the WF stones is also better. They are AGS000 (Ideal light return) H&A stones.

Thanks very much both and agreed, I have reached out to get side by side pics!

Also agree on the cut for WF ACA stones, just seems to be so much better.