Need help!! Which is the better Round Diamond?

[roxxx_m]

Based on the ASET Images provided and info?

Info for diamond on TOP:
0.51 / H / VS2
Measurements: 5.15 x 5.20 x 3.19


Table: 55%
Pavilion depth: 61.6%
Crown angle: 34.6
Pavilion angle: 40.7

Scored 1.0 on HCA

AGS Certified
---------------------------------------
Info for diamond on BOTTOM:
0.56 / H / VS1
Measurements: 5.15 x 5.20 x 3.19


Table: 54.5%
Pavilion depth: 61.6%
Crown angle: 34.1
Pavilion angle: 40.9

Scored 1.2 on HCA

AGS Certified

DIAMONDS HAVE A $320 price difference. Which would be the better option

 

[roxxx_m]

Re: Need help on this round diamond? Good buy or not??

Bump.....anyone please.

 

[roxxx_m]

Bumpppp

 

[ariel144]

I'm not an expert on MRB but the ASET on the 2nd one looks like it has less green. They are so almost identical...you should make diamond studs with them...LOL. If the vendor has them both in inventory I would ask the gemologist which he thought was the better performer.

 

[Dancing Fire]

Measurements: 5.15 x 5.20 x 3.19

same measurements on both stone?..

 

[roxxx_m]

Measurements: 5.15 x 5.20 x 3.19

same measurements on both stone?..

Sorry second stone is
5.30x5.34x3.27

 

[Dancing Fire]

Measurements: 5.15 x 5.20 x 3.19

same measurements on both stone?..

Sorry second stone is
5.30x5.34x3.27

flip a coin...both are well cut stone.

 

[roxxx_m]

I know, they both seem great to me.

If you were in my shoes though, which would you have chosen?

Any other help and opinions will do please!!!

 

[Dancing Fire]

I know, they both seem great to me.

If you were in my shoes though, which would you have chosen?

Any other help and opinions will do please!!!

if the stones were side by side i'd probably pick the .56ct b/c i will then be able to see the difference in diameter...

 

[04diamond<3]

I know, they both seem great to me.

If you were in my shoes though, which would you have chosen?

Any other help and opinions will do please!!!

if the stones were side by side i'd probably pick the .56ct b/c i will then be able to see the difference in diameter...

+1. If it comes down to stones that have the same cut, always go for the bigger one!!!! (Assuming color and clarity are within reason).

 

[roxxx_m]

Bump, anybody else?!!

 

[yssie]

No point in quibbling over nuances in the simulated ASET pics - too many hidden variables. Both are going to be beautiful stones, ask your vendor which they recommend - and why.

 

[Dreamer_D]

They are identical.

I would pick the bigger, or the less expensive, whichever would make you feel best about your purchase!