Need help picking princess cut diamond for engagement ring

[jsm172]

I am trying to decide which princess diamond is better. They are same price but there are some properties that I am confused on. I would post GIA reports but I cant get them to become an url, so i will list specs

Diamond 1:
Dimensions- 6.21x6.21x4.48
Carat- 1.41
Color- H
Clarity- VS2
Polish- VG
Symmetry- VG
Table %- 74%
Total depth- 72.1%
it has medium- very thick right next to table depth picture. What does this mean?



Diamond2:
Dimensions- 5.78x5.77x4.39
Carat- 1.41
Color- H
Clarity- VS1
Polish- VG
Symmetry- Good
Table %- 70%
Total Depth- 76.2%
it has thin - very thick.

Can someone explain the medium- very thick or the thin- very thick? and which one is better? TIA

 

[JulieN]

Re: Need help picking princess cut diamond for engagement ri

If you post the GIA report number, it is fast enough for us to look it up ourselves.

Any pictures? The first one is a lot spreadier. I would say the second one is undersized, I expect that kind of size from something around 1.2 cts.

Thickness description is the girdle.

 

[jsm172]

Re: Need help picking princess cut diamond for engagement ri

report numbers are 2148391988 and 1156159597

I would have put these first but i went to gia website and it said it couldnt find them

 

[jsm172]

Re: Need help picking princess cut diamond for engagement ri

http://www.bluenile.com/build-your-own-diamond-ring?builder=BYOR&forceStep=DIAMONDS_STEP&pid=LD03273175&track=rec

would this one be better than both of the others?

 

[JulieN]

Re: Need help picking princess cut diamond for engagement ri

can't really say much without quality pictures.