Need help picking one

[sledge]

Don't fall into the "my is bigger than yours" game. Besides at 0.15mm, it's barely noticeable.

For the small size difference and much better clarity I'm all for the 1.826ct.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I also would have to go for the 1.826 because it is a great stone overall. I do think 1.9 range stones are a good opportunity, however, I just can't handle the clarity in the magnified photo. I'm just a VS person in general, but there are some cleaner looking SI1's, too.

You'd have to know whether she would love the slight extra size over having a clean, VS stone. It' part mental and part visual!