Need Help deciding between 2 diamonds

[dishingout]

I need some expert opinion comparison between these 2 diamonds. I can''t seem to pick one. The price on both is very close. I would appreciate any insight

Diamond # 1

Measurement: 8.31 - 8.25 x 5.02
Carat weight: 2.08
Cut: Premium
Color: I
Clarity: VS2
Depth%: 60.6%
Table%: 59%
Symmetry: V.Good
Polish: Exct
Girdle: Thn-Med, Fac​

Diamond # 2

Measurement: 7.97 x 8.01 x 5.02
Carat weight: 1.98
Cut: Premium
Color: H
Clarity: VS2
Depth%: 62.8%
Table%: 58%
Symmetry: V.Good
Polish: V.Good
Girdle: M-TK

 

[yahui]

What's the shape of the diamond? Round, princess, etc. I look at princess cuts all day and sometimes I forget everyone else is looking at rounds.

 

[dishingout]

Ahhhh Forgot the most important part sorry.

Its a Round Cut

 

[oldminer]

I would prefer the 2ct+ stone based on a non-visual look at the specs. I don't like thick girdles or stones that do not look their size. One must examine both to see brilliancy and which one looks "RIGHT" to them, but by the limited numbers you presented, the first seems better than the second stone.