Need advise on 2 diamonds

[diamonddumb]

I have finally narrowed down my search for a diamond. Below are the specs. I would love the hear some comments as to which ring may be the better buy.
Thanks.

Diamond #1:

Cut - Round
Carat - 1.49
Color - F
Clarity - VS2
Table - 58%
Depth - 63.3%
Girdle - Thin to thick (faceted)
Polish - Very good
Symmetry - Very good
Culet - None
Flourescnece - None
Grading Lab - GIA
Cost - $10,800

Diamond #2:
Cut - Round
Dimensions - 7.3*7.38*4.53
Carat - 1.5
Color - F
Clarity - SI1
Table - 60%
Depth - 61.7%
Girdle - Medium - thick (faceted)
Polish - Good
Symmetry - Good
Culet - Very small
Flourescnece - None
Grading Lab - GIA
Cost - $11,300

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

Neither will have excellent cut.